Amanda Overmyer’s real crime is her singing on American Idol?

American Idol finalist, Amanda Overmyer’s apparent checkered past is coming back to haunt her.

The National Enquirer (via Showbiz Spy) reports that Mandy was arrested October 14, 2006 in Crawfordsville, Indiana for drunk driving. She also has a string of driving offenses including going 100mph in a 45mph zone and running a red light.

Mandy also admitted on the show that shortly after “Hollywood week” she got into a car accident with a semi-truck that left her with a cracked rib and a busted head.

Her 2006 mug shot above indicates she’s had the Bride of Frankenstein look going for quite a while.

Last night, Amanda killed the Kansas song “Carry On Wayward Son,” but no in a good way. So far no charges for the murdered song have been filed.